Mandarin or Cantonese? Just what do I study?

Mandarin-vs.-Cantonese-which-to-choose

If you’ve made a decision to learn Chinese, the next big question is whether to learn Cantonese or Mandarin Chinese.

You might be wondering which one of those two will help you most in the future in terms of career prospects. Or which one might be easier to learn. Or did you even realize that there was a difference between them?

So let’s look in more detail at some of the key issues you’ll have to take into consideration to help facilitate your decision of whether to learn Cantonese or Mandarin:

1. Facts you should know about the languages before making the decision!

You may know that the Chinese language is very diverse

China’s population was estimated by Worldometers at close to 1.4 billion people in 2014, making it home to just over 19% of the world’s population and there are some 56 languages spoken by China’s recognised ethnic groups, according to Wikipedia. However, whilst Hanyu, or Han, is the predominant language and spans eight primary dialect groups, accents and variations in regional dialects differ from each other to such a degree that sometimes even the same language becomes mutually unintelligible.

Chinese family enjoying a meal

In the past, people were more likely to use their own regional dialects to communicate, and this became a challenge as people from northern areas such as Harbin could not understand people from southern areas such as Guangzhou. To overcome this and other related issues, the Chinese government’s policy has long been to teach the younger generations “standard Mandarin Chinese”, and these days the vast majority of people can usually speak both Mandarin and their own regional dialect fluently.

2. Where are Cantonese and Mandarin spoken in China?

Here’s a helpful map showing the main areas where Cantonese and Mandarin are spoken

(1) Cantonese is one of the leading regional variations of Chinese

The red coloured area shows where Cantonese is predominantly spoken:

 Map-of-Cantonese-speaking-region

It is estimated that somewhere between 50-60 million people in the Guangzhou provincial areas, plus Hong Kong and Macau, speak Cantonese (not to mention those in overseas Chinese communities in SE Asia). It’s also the dominant Chinese dialect throughout most overseas Chinese communities in places such as the US, Canada and in European countries.

(2) Mandarin Chinese is prevalent

And the rest of the country?

Did you guess right? That’s it: Mandarin Chinese.

Not surprisingly, even though most people speak Mandarin, the words and phrase usage can be influenced by local accents or dialects.

Still, you will find that Mandarin spoken in Beijing is not quite the same as in Shanghai—or even Taipei in Taiwan.

For example, in Taiwan, “Subway” is: 捷运(jié yùn), while in mainland China it’s: 地铁(dì tiě). This is similar to using “Underground” in British English or “Subway” in American English.

However, most native Chinese speakers can understand such differences based on context. Plus, the internet definitely helps. For example, people from the Mainland enjoy watching TV programs from Taiwan, and they are already getting used to Taiwanese accents and speech patterns, and the opposite also holds true.

3. Cantonese (and other dialects) vs Mandarin: what’s the real situation in China?

Regional dialects

Although each region has its own dialects, Mandarin is widely spoken throughout Mainland China and Taiwan, especially by the younger generations and also for governmental affairs.

While it’s easy to find various data on the internet about which part of China speaks which dialect(s), most such data is generic and somewhat outdated. As China’s economy continues to grow, people are always moving throughout the country (e.g. from the countryside to first or second tier cities) due to a variety of reasons, including business, family, house prices, etc. From our observations, “standardized” Mandarin has become dominant throughout China.

To give a concrete example, let’s say you work in Shanghai. No matter whether you are holding a business meeting or just walking into a 7-11 convenience store, people will generally expect you to communicate in Mandarin instead of in the local Shanghainese dialect. Given that people are always moving around the country for business or leisure, a standardized language base is, clearly, far more effective.

On the other hand, dialects are still used among family members or close friends/colleagues from the same areas.

4. Mandarin Chinese and Cantonese: some key differences

Listening to people speaking Mandarin and Cantonese can seem as if the languages are totally different—yet they do have many similarities, especially in grammar and characters.

An example about how similar or different Mandarin and Cantonese can be is demonstrated in the following simple sentence:

Spoken-Cantonese-and-Mandarin

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

From this example, it can be seen that there are “three levels” of similarity or dissimilarity between Cantonese and Mandarin:

  • Similarities

Characters: the characters are the same except for the second character in the above two sentences. Usually, most Chinese characters can be both read by Cantonese and Mandarin speakers although, on occasions, the meaning may be different.

  • Partly similar/different

Grammar: the grammar has many similarities and the order of words is also generally the same, but not exactly, for certain expressions. The word order for “I am Norwegian” in Cantonese and Mandarin is the same.

  • Differences

Speaking: the speaker of one does not, usually, understand the other as the sounds of Cantonese and Mandarin are totally different. For examples, Cantonese has more tones (7) than Mandarin (4).

5. Coming back to the question: should I learn Cantonese or Mandarin?

Cantonese:

The Cantonese language/dialect is renowned as being difficult for foreigners to learn.

However, with a bit of effort, it can be done and if you wonder: Why should I learn Cantonese? then here are some pointers:

  • Learning Cantonese is a good idea if you are going to work or live in Hong Kong or the nearby Guangzhou province, as many locals (especially the older generations) cannot speak Mandarin well;
  • Cantonese will be helpful for advanced Chinese learners starting to read ancient Chinese poetry, as many words rhyme in Cantonese but not in Mandarin;
  • If you enjoy Cantonese songs or movies, learning Cantonese can help you understand what’s going on, especially given that such things are popular in China and overseas Chinese communities.

Alternatively:

  • The chances are that people won’t understand you if you speak Cantonese in the north or north-east regions of the country, as Cantonese is not widely used in those areas;
  • Most Cantonese speakers might be able to teach you some useful phrases but will struggle to explain the grammar systematically or teach you Cantonese pinyin as they probably just picked the language up from parents or friends;
  • I can be relatively difficult to find good Cantonese learning resources, although tools are certainly available, some of which we recommend further below.

Mandarin:

It appears that most people choose to learn Mandarin, in view of the following:

  • It’s easier to find people to teach you Mandarin, including some of your Chinese friends who have learned “proper Mandarin”, and who may be able to teach you the language step-by-step;
  • More Mandarin learning materials are available from all sorts of sources and at a variety of levels;
  • With the current economic growth of China, it’s likely that Mandarin will be a key language of the future.

Alternatively:

  • Knowing how to speak Mandarin is not such a unique skill as compared to in the past, as more and more foreigners live in China and have learned the language;
  • For someone whose English is not their native tongue, it might be better to, firstly, improve their English as more and more Chinese students and business people across the country are learning English.

To summarize: some people like the sounds or music or culture of a new language or simply love the challenge of learning how to speak Chinese for their personal benefit. Whether you plan to learn Mandarin of Cantonese, it’s important to determine what your objectives are before you begin.

6. Resources to learn Mandarin/Cantonese

Learning Mandarin or CantoneseSome of the most frequently recommended resources include:

Pleco: this resource was the number 1 ranking resource in our survey, and is an integrated Chinese/English dictionary/document reader/flashcard system with full screen handwriting input and live camera-based character look-ups.

Skritter is an amazing program suitable for Smartphones or PC’s to help with learning to write Chinese characters. It offers tone practice, stroke-level feedback and audio playback etc. It also even suggests corrections for any mistakes if you make them.

Italki: a great platform to help you to find native speakers to practice languages with.

For more Chinese learning resources, you can take a look at: How to learn Chinese where you can find many free resources as recommended by more than 60 Chinese learners.

Decision, decisions…

Your choice should be primarily on your purpose and motivations to learn Chinese. It’s important to remember to enjoy the pleasure a language will bring you while you are learning it as, obviously, this will make learning that much easier!

———————-

This article was brought to you by Learn Mandarin Now, a widely read blog with tips and ideas to help you on your journey to learn Mandarin, including the popular “How to Learn Chinese: 50 bloggers tell you how“.

“It’s Raining Husbands” and Other Idioms Translated into Different Languages

A bull in a China shop idiom

The following post is from Paul, an English teacher who lives in Argentina. Paul writes on behalf of Language Trainers, a language teaching service which offers foreign-language level tests as well as other free language-learning resources on their … [Continue reading]

5 Winning Strategies to Build a Successful Language Learning Routine

Climbing a staircase reaching goal

Learning a language is a long, and difficult process – I should know, I’ve been teaching English to foreign students for 3 years, and every day I’m reminded of the obstacles that come into the way of reaching that elusive goal that is “fluency”. … [Continue reading]

Language Learning, Scaffolding, and the Zone of Proximal Development

Zone of Proximal Development brain research

Not so long ago, on a bright Sunday afternoon, I was browsing the website of one of the United States’ leading public policy organizations, Brookings Institution, and I stumbled across a series of Essays on Character and Opportunity. The short … [Continue reading]

How Many Words Can You Memorize A Day?

Words on a table

Eric is a beginner language learner eager to learn French. He knows that fluency in la langue de Molière will boost his career prospects, and while he’s not a big fan of French cinema (is there such a person?), he can’t wait to travel to southern … [Continue reading]

The Top 10 Best Translation Resources for Learning Languages

itranslate4eu-logo

This article introduces you to a list of translation services, tools and apps that you will make your life a whole lot easier over the course of your foreign language learning journey. They are ranked in no particular order; frankly, each of them has … [Continue reading]

The 10 Top Ways to Learn Mandarin Chinese

Top 10 ways to learn Mandarin Chinese

Want to learn Chinese.…? Just where do I start? So, you want to learn Mandarin Chinese? Really get to grips with the language? Master the tones and read the characters? Well, we all know that starting to learn any new language can be a challenge. … [Continue reading]

Tuttle Asian Languages: “Elementary” and “Continuing” Series Review

Tuttle Elementary Series

Average cost of the method (paperback): $23 to $40 Available in: 6 languages (Arabic, Hindi, Japanese, Korean, Tagalog, Vietnamese) Type of method: All-encompassing method available in print (paperback or hardback) with audio CD/MP3, covering … [Continue reading]

So, Are Fillers Okay to Use When, Um, Learning a Foreign Language?

Talking on the phone

Fillers are everywhere: they’re the ums, uhs, and likes that sneak their way into our speech, often times without us even realizing it. Indeed, fillers, also known as disfluencies, carry no semantic value, but they are used abundantly in natural … [Continue reading]

Learning Chinese: Myths Busted

Learning Chinese Myths Busted

Today we have Beijing-based interpreter Chris Parker, who runs the website "Fluent in Mandarin",  writing on Lingholic. Chris sheds some light on what it really takes to learn Mandarin Chinese, and why it isn't as hard as most people would tend to … [Continue reading]